Creamy Homemade Butterscotch Pie

Pinterest Facebook WhatsApp X Yummly

This Creamy Homemade Butterscotch Pie is the perfect blend of rich, buttery caramel flavor and a smooth, velvety custard filling. Made with brown sugar, butter, and vanilla, this dessert delivers a deep, warm sweetness in every bite. Topped with fluffy homemade whipped cream, it’s a decadent treat for any occasion. Whether you’re preparing it for the holidays, a family gathering, or just a personal indulgence, this pie is guaranteed to impress.

Preparation Phase & Tools to Use

Essential Tools and Equipment

To make this pie successfully, you’ll need the following:

Saucepan – For cooking the butterscotch filling
Whisk – To ensure a smooth, lump-free mixture
Mixing Bowls – For whisking egg yolks and preparing the whipped topping
Measuring Cups and Spoons – For accurate ingredient measurements
Pie Dish – To hold the baked pie crust and filling
Hand or Stand Mixer – For whipping the cream topping
Plastic Wrap – To cover and chill the pie

Preparation Tips

Have all ingredients measured and ready before starting.
Whisk continuously while cooking the filling to prevent lumps.
Use room temperature eggs for smoother incorporation into the filling.
Chill the pie for at least 4 hours for the best texture.

Ingredients

For the Pie Crust

1 pre-baked pie crust (store-bought or homemade)

For the Butterscotch Filling

1 cup packed light brown sugar
1/4 cup unsalted butter
1/4 cup all-purpose flour
2 1/2 cups whole milk
4 large egg yolks
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1/4 teaspoon salt

For the Whipped Topping

1 cup heavy whipping cream
2 tablespoons granulated sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla extract

Step-by-Step Directions

Step 1: Make the Butterscotch Filling

In a medium saucepan, melt the brown sugar and butter over medium heat. Stir until the sugar dissolves and the mixture turns slightly caramelized.
Add the flour and cook for 1-2 minutes, stirring constantly to create a roux that will help thicken the filling.
Gradually whisk in the milk, ensuring the mixture remains smooth. Cook over medium heat until it thickens (about 5-7 minutes).
In a separate bowl, whisk the egg yolks. Slowly add 1/2 cup of the hot butterscotch mixture into the yolks while whisking to temper them and prevent scrambling.
Pour the tempered yolk mixture back into the saucepan. Continue cooking over low heat, stirring constantly, until the filling thickens further.
Remove from heat and stir in the vanilla extract and salt.
Pour the filling into the pre-baked pie crust, smoothing out the top.
Cover and refrigerate for at least 4 hours, or until the filling is fully set.

Step 2: Prepare the Whipped Topping

In a mixing bowl, combine the heavy whipping cream, granulated sugar, and vanilla extract.
Using a hand mixer or stand mixer, beat the mixture on medium-high speed until stiff peaks form (about 3-5 minutes).

Step 3: Assemble and Serve

Once the pie is fully chilled, spread or pipe the whipped cream on top.
Garnish with additional butterscotch drizzle or a sprinkle of sea salt for a sweet-and-salty contrast.
Slice and serve cold for the best texture.

Recipe Notes & Variations

For a deeper butterscotch flavor, substitute 1 tablespoon of dark brown sugar for a portion of the light brown sugar.
If you prefer a lighter filling, substitute half-and-half for half of the whole milk.
To add extra texture, sprinkle chopped pecans or toffee bits on top before serving.
The whipped topping can be flavored with a dash of cinnamon or bourbon for a unique twist.

This creamy homemade butterscotch pie is a simple yet elegant dessert that’s sure to become a favorite. Prepare it ahead of time and enjoy a smooth, indulgent slice with every bite.

Serving Suggestions

This Creamy Homemade Butterscotch Pie pairs well with a variety of flavors and textures. Here are some great serving ideas:

Warm Beverage Pairings
- Freshly brewed coffee or espresso to balance the sweetness
- A cup of chai tea or spiced black tea for a cozy pairing
- A glass of hot chocolate for an ultra-indulgent treat
Cold Beverage Pairings
- Cold brew coffee with a hint of vanilla or caramel
- Milk (plain, almond, or oat) for a classic dessert experience
- A chilled butterscotch milkshake for double the flavor
Additional Garnishes
- A drizzle of warm butterscotch sauce for extra richness
- A sprinkle of flaky sea salt to enhance the caramelized flavor
- Chopped toasted pecans or crushed toffee bits for added crunch
Best Ways to Serve
- Serve chilled for the best texture and flavor
- Slice with a sharp knife, wiping it clean between each cut for clean slices
- Add whipped cream just before serving to keep it fresh and airy

Common Mistakes to Avoid & How to Perfect the Recipe

Even simple recipes can go wrong without careful attention to detail. Avoid these common mistakes to achieve the perfect butterscotch pie.

1. Not Stirring the Butterscotch Filling Constantly

Brown sugar and butter can burn quickly if not stirred continuously.
Solution: Whisk constantly while cooking the filling to ensure a smooth texture.

2. Scrambling the Egg Yolks

Adding hot liquid to eggs too quickly can cook them, resulting in a grainy filling.
Solution: Temper the eggs by slowly adding a small amount of the hot mixture while whisking constantly before returning everything to the saucepan.

3. Not Cooking the Filling Long Enough

If removed from heat too early, the filling may be too thin and won’t set properly.
Solution: Cook until the mixture coats the back of a spoon and thickens significantly before chilling.

4. Skipping the Chill Time

The pie needs time to firm up, or it will be too soft when sliced.
Solution: Chill for at least 4 hours, but overnight is best for a firmer set.

5. Overbeating the Whipped Cream

Whipped cream can turn grainy if overmixed.
Solution: Beat only until stiff peaks form, stopping before it becomes lumpy.

Side Dish Recommendations

Although this pie is delicious on its own, pairing it with the right side dish can elevate the dessert experience. Here are eight great options:

1. Fresh Berry Salad

A mix of strawberries, raspberries, and blueberries lightly sweetened with honey and lemon juice balances the richness of the pie.

2. Candied Pecans

The caramelized crunch of candied pecans adds a nutty contrast to the creamy pie.

3. Dark Chocolate Bark

A few small pieces of dark chocolate bark with sea salt provide a bittersweet complement to the sweet butterscotch.

4. Vanilla Ice Cream

A scoop of vanilla bean ice cream adds an extra creamy element that enhances the overall flavor.

5. Spiced Apple Compote

A warm apple compote with cinnamon and nutmeg brings in a fruity depth that pairs well with the caramel-like notes of the pie.

6. Espresso or Cold Brew Coffee

A strong cup of espresso or lightly sweetened cold brew coffee cuts through the pie’s sweetness and enhances the butterscotch flavor.

7. Shortbread Cookies

Light, buttery shortbread cookies provide a crisp and delicate pairing without overpowering the pie.

8. Salted Caramel Popcorn

A handful of salted caramel popcorn brings in a crunchy and slightly salty contrast, making each bite of pie more exciting.

By choosing the right side dish or beverage, you can create a well-rounded dessert experience that highlights the rich, buttery flavors of this butterscotch pie.

Recipe Tips for the Best Butterscotch Pie

Use High-Quality Ingredients – Fresh dairy products and pure vanilla extract enhance the flavor.
Cook the Filling Until Thick – The custard should coat the back of a spoon before removing it from the heat.
Chill for Optimal Texture – Refrigerating for at least 4 hours ensures the filling sets properly.
Make Ahead for Convenience – This pie can be made a day in advance, allowing flavors to deepen.
Whip the Cream Just Before Serving – This keeps the topping fresh and airy.

Storage and Reheating Instructions

Refrigeration

Store leftover pie covered in plastic wrap or an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 4 days.
Keep the whipped cream topping separate if storing for more than a day to prevent it from deflating.

Freezing

The butterscotch filling can be frozen, but freezing the whole pie may affect the texture.
To freeze slices, wrap them in plastic wrap and place them in an airtight container for up to 2 months.
Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before serving.

Reheating

This pie is best served chilled, but if you prefer a slightly warm filling, allow a slice to sit at room temperature for 15 minutes before serving.
Avoid microwaving, as it can alter the custard’s texture.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can I use dark brown sugar instead of light brown sugar?

Yes, dark brown sugar will create a deeper, more intense caramel flavor.

2. How do I prevent lumps in my butterscotch filling?

Whisk constantly while adding milk and cook the mixture over medium heat to ensure a smooth consistency.

3. Can I use a store-bought graham cracker crust instead?

Yes, a graham cracker crust adds a slightly different texture and complements the butterscotch flavor well.

4. What can I use instead of heavy cream for the topping?

Cool Whip or coconut whipped cream can be used as substitutes.

5. Can I make this pie without eggs?

Yes, replace the egg yolks with 2 tablespoons of cornstarch mixed with milk to help thicken the filling.

6. How do I get clean slices when cutting the pie?

Use a sharp knife and wipe it clean between cuts for smooth slices.

7. Can I make the butterscotch filling ahead of time?

Yes, you can make the filling a day in advance and store it in the refrigerator. Whisk it before pouring into the crust to restore its smooth texture.

8. Why is my filling too runny?

The custard likely wasn’t cooked long enough. Make sure it thickens before removing it from the heat.

Conclusion

This creamy homemade butterscotch pie is a rich and indulgent dessert that combines the deep, caramelized flavor of butterscotch with a smooth custard filling. Whether served at a holiday gathering or enjoyed as a personal treat, this pie delivers a perfect balance of sweetness and texture. By following the recipe tips and avoiding common mistakes, you can achieve a flawless butterscotch pie every time.

Make it ahead, pair it with your favorite beverage, and enjoy a classic dessert that is sure to become a favorite.